With average credit card rates hovering near 22% and the cost of living continuing to stretch household budgets, paying off large credit card balances can feel nearly impossible right now. In fact, many borrowers are struggling just to cover the minimum payments, let alone make progress on the principal. And with inflation cooling but not reversing, that squeeze doesn't appear to be letting up anytime soon, so it's important to deal with your credit card debt as soon as possible.

But when it comes to credit card debt, the traditional advice of "just pay the balance off" can feel hollow, especially if you're dealing with a balance of $10,000 or more. Most cardholders don't just have that type of cash lying around, after all, and as the interest charges compound, the total costs climb — making it even more difficult to get rid of. That's part of why many cardholders have been turning to debt relief options like debt settlement instead. 

With debt settlement, the goal is to negotiate with your creditors to pay less than the full balance owed. It's a strategy that can help you escape a seemingly endless debt cycle, but it's not for everyone. So, how do you know if it's right for you? Below, we'll examine seven signs that it could be.

.

7 signs that credit card debt settlement is right for you

Here are a few telltale signs that credit card debt settlement could be the right move for you now:

Your minimum payments exceed 20% of your take-home income

When credit card payments start consuming more than a fifth of your monthly income, you've crossed into dangerous territory. Most financial experts typically recommend keeping all debt payments under 20% of your gross income, so if just the minimum payments required on your credit card are hitting that take-home pay threshold, chances are you're in serious trouble. When you reach this point, though, debt settlement can provide breathing room that traditional payment plans simply can't offer.

.

You're only making minimum payments with no progress on the principal

The reality is that minimum payments are designed to go mainly toward interest charges and maximize profit for credit card companies, not to help you become debt-free. That means that you can faithfully make the minimum payments on your credit cards for months or years but still have your balances remain stubbornly high. This issue is particularly frustrating, but debt settlement can break this cycle by negotiating a reduced balance that you're able to pay off.

You're considering borrowing from retirement accounts

The moment you start eyeing your 401(k) or individual retirement account to pay your credit card debt, it's time to consider debt settlement. Raiding your retirement accounts triggers penalties, results in extra taxes and permanently damages your long-term financial security. The money you withdraw won't benefit from decades of compound growth either. Debt settlement can impact your finances temporarily, but it also preserves your retirement savings. This generally makes it a better choice than sacrificing your future financial security for your current debt obligations.

Your credit utilization is maxed out across multiple cards

When you're carrying card balances that are at or near the credit limits on multiple cards, you've lost the flexibility that credit was supposed to provide. More importantly, maxed-out cards indicate you're no longer using credit as a financial tool but as a financial crutch. However, debt settlement can help eliminate unmanageable balances and allow you to rebuild more responsibly. High utilization ratios devastate your credit score anyway, so the additional impact may be less significant than you think.

You're juggling payments and considering cash advances

Using cash advances to make credit card payments on your bills or other cards signals a debt spiral that's unlikely to resolve through traditional means. Cash advances carry higher interest rates and immediate fees, making your debt situation exponentially worse with each transaction. And, this type of juggling act often precedes missed payments and default anyway. Debt settlement, on the other hand, allows you to address the problem proactively rather than waiting until you're forced into choosing from worse options.

Medical bills or job loss triggered the debt accumulation

If your credit card debt stems from circumstances beyond your control, like medical emergencies, job loss or other financial shocks, debt settlement becomes more defensible both practically and ethically. These situations often create debt loads that were never sustainable given your actual income and expenses. And, unlike debt accumulated through overspending, circumstantial debt represents a genuine financial hardship. Creditors and debt collectors often view these cases more favorably, potentially leading to better settlement terms.

The traditional credit counseling timeline isn't realistic

If you've talked to a credit counselor about a debt management plan and have found that the timeline stretches five to seven years or more, debt settlement might offer a faster resolution. Debt settlement typically resolves your debts within two to four years. That allows you to move forward rather than remaining trapped in extended repayment cycles that may not survive job changes, health issues or other life events.

The bottom line

Debt settlement isn't right for everyone, but if you notice these warning signs, it could indicate that this debt relief strategy is a viable option worth exploring. While debt settlement will impact your credit score temporarily and may come with other potential repercussions, it can provide the fresh start needed to rebuild your financial life on more sustainable terms. Before you make any decisions, though, it could help to speak with a debt relief expert to understand your specific options and the possible outcomes.